Mumbai: India’s 5-year air-pollution-associated health invoice from burning crop stubble will pay for approximately seven hundred ideal All India Institutes of Medical Sciences or India’s 2019 principal authorities health budget almost 21 times over, according to an IndiaSpend analysis of facts from a new look at.

The burning of crop residue or stubble stays a pivotal contributor to air pollution over northern India, notwithstanding a ban by using the National Green Tribunal (NGT) in November 2015, and could price you. S. A. Over Rs 2 lakh crore annually, or three times India’s imperative health budget, or Rs thirteen lakh crore over five years–equal to one.7% of India’s gross home product (GDP) or enough, as we stated, to construct seven-hundred AIIMS hospitals, in step with a 2019 take a look at by means of the International Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI), a research advocacy primarily based in Washington D.C., USA.


Crop-residue burning reasons a collective loss of 14.Nine million years of wholesome existence many of the seventy five million residents of Delhi, Haryana and Punjab–seventy two.5 days or a 5th of a 12 months in step with person within the three states–whose danger for acute breathing contamination (ARI) rises threefold because of publicity to pollutants, the take a look at says.

“We located that 14% of ARI instances could be prevented if crop burning were removed,” Samuel Scott, IFPRI research fellow and co-writer of the file, informed IndiaSpend.

Crop residue burning within the north-western states of Punjab and Haryana is a crucial cause why ranges of particulate matter up to two.5 micron in length (PM 2.5) within the air spike by means of 20 instances in neighbouring Delhi during harvest season, and is a significant risk factor for ARI in all three states, in particular among children younger than 5.

In winter, mainly, sixty four% of Delhi’s PM 2.Five pollutants comes from outside the national capital, as IndiaSpend reported on September three, 2019.

Agricultural fires in the states of Punjab and Haryana throughout October and November for pollutants in Delhi, primarily based on 15-yr satellite statistics (2002-2016), showed an increasing fashion in agricultural fires (as much as 617 in line with 12 months in 2017), according to a have a look at by using Hiren Jathava, studies scientist, NASA published with the aid of the Taiwan Association for Aerosol Research in 2018.

Between 1990 and 2016, indoor air pollutants declined over northern India due to efforts to lessen the burning of solid gas for household use, however, outdoor air pollution multiplied by using sixteen.6%, says the IFPRI have a look at.

Why stubble burning keeps

The important ministry of agriculture and farmers welfare’s (MoAFW) national coverage for the control of crop residue, announced in 2014, recommended coverage measures to minimize crop residue burning. The MoAFW announced an amount of Rs 1,151. Nine crores for 2018-20–zero.Five% of the whole budget of Rs 2,22,362 crore of Punjab and Haryana in 2019-20–to subsidize the usage of auxiliary farm device to do away with crop residue, along with Straw Management Systems, instead of crop burning.

The NGT ban followed the following 12 months. The tribunal has repeatedly issued orders directing the Punjab and Haryana nation governments ‘to evaluate steps taken to forestall crop burning incidents periodically,’ yet crop stubble burning incidents hold.

In 2018-19, the two states collectively spent over Rs 400 crore–round Rs 15 lakh for every agricultural employee within the rules–to prevent stubble burning. Using satellite-based far-flung sensing, Punjab and Haryana detected seventy-five,563 events of crop residue burning in Punjab, Haryana and Uttar Pradesh at some point of 2018. Punjab identified 6,193 instances and recovered Rs 19.02 lakh as repayment from farmers who burned crop residue even after the ban, while the government of Haryana diagnosed three,997 cases and recovered Rs 31.Eighty-two lakh as repayment, Lok Sabha statistics display.

Burning stubble maintains due to the fact its miles the only alternative left for farmers, Devinder Sharma, a meals and trade coverage analyst primarily based in Punjab, told IndiaSpend. “The great way to distribute the [MoAFW] subsidy would have been to provide it at once to the farmers as opposed to subsidizing the machines. The agricultural lands in Punjab and Haryana are already over-mechanized, and the mechanization scheme is a burden for farmers. Farmers are prepared to manage the residue if the price range is supplied, but agriculture is being sacrificed to preserve marketplace reforms alive employing selling and selling machines to farmers,” Sharma stated.

Not handiest do farmers locate the value of hiring equipment expensive; they are saying the machines aren’t required and working them desires specialized schooling.

A Straw Management System connected with a integrate harvester fees Rs 1.12 lakh, a Happy Seeder that clears fields of crop residue Rs 1.51 lakh and a paddy straw chopper Rs 2.Eighty lakh after availing the eighty% subsidy underneath the MoAFW’s important agriculture ministry’s recommendations for crop residue management. The average month-to-month profits consistent with the rural household in Punjab is Rs 18,059 and in Haryana is Rs 14,434, as per agricultural information 2017 released through the government of India.

The subsidy furnished with the aid of the authorities is for two years, and then mechanization expenses a farmer Rs five,000 in line with an acre, JS Samra, former CEO of the MoAFW’s National Rainfed Area Authority, informed IndiaSpend. Machines which include the Happy Seeder are usable for most effective 20-25 days in the course of harvest, Samra stated, and lie unused for the rest of the yr. “A farm system typically works for 400-500 hours yearly. A farm device that doesn’t include paintings for two hundred-300 hours isn’t feasible. These machines are not like a tractor that a farmer can place to a different use,” Samra stated.

Small and tenant farmers in Punjab and Haryana–like their counterparts throughout us of a–have been in distress because agriculture has grown to be unremunerative as a source of livelihood. There have been protests in Punjab and Haryana these days, along with towards what farmers call lousy management of the NGT order to ban stubble burning.

Producing biogas from crop residue is the manner ahead

The predominant step to ease the issue of stubble burning is to provide price range directly to farmers, says Devinder Sharma. “A call for to the leader minister of Punjab changed into made with the aid of the competition in 2018 to release a fund of Rs three,000 crores to be dispensed to the farmers in 2018 because the farmers demand Rs 5,000-6,000 per acre. If the stated amount can deliver down the danger of the trouble inflicting a lack of 2 lakh crore, then it has to be furnished. The manner of residue control have to be left to the farmers,” adds Sharma.

A secondary approach can be to carry inside the use of smooth power for better management of crop residue, Samra informed IndiaSpend. Crop residue can be used for mushroom cultivation and paper manufacturing. Paddy straw can also be used to generate power, says Samra, however, this technique is now redundant and uneconomical because the inline with-unit value of sun and wind strength is around Rs 3 at the same time as strength from straw expenses Rs 7-eight according to a unit, in keeping with Samra.

The today’s and most viable approach, Samra stated, is to produce compressed herbal gasoline (CNG) from residue via an organic manner that doesn’t provide any additional gas or ash and gives CNG of the equal first-rate as that derived from fossil fuels.

The DBT-Institute of Chemical Technology Centre is processing the bio-CNG generation for Energy Biosciences in Mumbai, says Samra, who serves as a consultant to the project. Germany-based Verbio Biofuel and Technology is setting up a bio-CNG plant at Bhutal Kalan village of Sangrur district in Punjab at an approximate cost of Rs 75 crore.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *